First Date Disasters: Hilarious Tales of Love Gone Wrong

Funny stories and some surprisingly useful tips on what not to do during your first date!

DATING

6/25/20242 min read

Let’s face it, guys. First dates are like job interviews, but instead of landing a position, you’re trying to land a second date. You prepare, you try to look cool, and then… things go hilariously wrong. Here are some funny first date disaster stories from the male perspective, each packed with awkwardness and learning moments.

1. The ‘Accidentally Overdressed’ Catastrophe

Story:
"I wanted to impress her, so I went all out—suit, tie, the works. I showed up at the restaurant, only to realize that she was wearing jeans and a T-shirt. The restaurant wasn’t fancy either. I spent the entire date feeling like an undercover FBI agent at a backyard barbecue."

Learning:
Before you channel your inner James Bond, check the dress code. It’s okay to look sharp, but you don’t want to feel like you’ve accidentally walked into the wrong movie set. A quick 'What’s the vibe?' message beforehand saves you from standing out like a sore thumb.

2. The Gym Bro Mistake

Story:
"She told me she loved being active, so I suggested we do something fun—like a casual hike. What I didn’t realize is that she was a legit marathon runner. I was out of breath 20 minutes in, drenched in sweat, while she was chatting away like we were at a coffee shop. By the end, I was basically crawling back to the car, and she looked like she could do another round."

Learning:
Know your limits, guys. It’s great to suggest an active date, but if your idea of exercise is lifting the TV remote, maybe skip the extreme sports. Or at least pick something you can both enjoy without needing an oxygen tank halfway through.

3. The Mismatched Order Mishap

Story:
"I wanted to look adventurous, so I suggested sushi even though I’d never eaten it. I got there and realized I had no idea what to order, so I tried to mimic her choices. I ended up with something raw and slimy, and I gagged. Loudly. I spent the rest of the date pretending to love it while fighting for my life."

Learning:
If you’re not familiar with the cuisine, it’s okay to say so! Trying something new is great, but gagging in front of your date? Not so much. Stick to what you know, or ask for recommendations to avoid a culinary disaster.

4. The Wallet Fail

Story:
"I picked her up and drove us to the restaurant. Things were going great until the check came. I reached for my wallet… and it wasn’t there. Turns out I left it on the counter at home. She had to pay, and I felt like the biggest idiot. Needless to say, there wasn’t a second date."

Learning:
Always double-check your essentials: keys, phone, wallet. There’s nothing worse than that sinking feeling of realizing you forgot your wallet just as the check arrives. It’s not about who pays, but being prepared goes a long way in showing that you’ve got it together.

5. The Overshare Trap

Story:
"I was super nervous, so I started rambling. And when I ramble, I overshare. I found myself telling her all about my awkward teenage years, my weird family traditions, and even the time I got dumped via text in high school. By the time I realized I hadn’t asked her a single question, it was too late. She was already looking for an exit."

Learning:
It’s cool to be open, but pace yourself. First dates aren’t therapy sessions, so keep it light and balanced. Ask questions, listen, and avoid unleashing your entire life story before the appetizers arrive.